All 7 Best Josie Totah Movies Ranked (Best to Worst)

Anchored by Jesse Plemons and Molly Shannon, this poignant tragicomedy captures the messy reality of a struggling comedy writer moving home to care for his dying mother. Director Chris Kelly balances agonizing grief with awkward humor, resulting in an unflinching look at suburban family dynamics during a terminal illness. The narrative succeeds because it refuses to lean into cheap sentimentality, choosing instead to find truth in uncomfortable silences and fractured relationships. Totah enters this delicate ecosystem with absolute confidence, delivering a sharp, memorable supporting turn that cuts through the sorrow with pitch-perfect comedic timing and genuine heart, marking an early career high-water mark.

Jon Watts revitalized the friendly neighborhood web-slinger by shrinking the stakes down to the awkward realities of teenage life, teenage crushes, and academic decathlons. Balancing high-octane superhero spectacle with a classic John Hughes coming-of-age sensibility, the movie captures the vibrant, messy energy of attending a public high school in Queens. Michael Keaton's grounded villainy adds genuine tension, keeping Peter Parker grounded between saving the city and worrying about homecoming. Amidst a sprawling, diverse ensemble of high schoolers, Totah carves out a distinct presence with effortless wit and snappy delivery, proving entirely at home within the colossal machinery of a Marvel blockbuster.

Amy Poehler's riotous adaptation of Jennifer Mathieu's novel brings intersectional feminist fury straight to the fluorescent-lit hallways of a suburban high school. Driven by a defiant handmade zine, a quiet teen ignites a silent revolution against rampant institutional double standards and toxic locker-room behavior. The film pulses with authentic youthful anger, refusing to sanitize the very real friction of standing up to entrenched patriarchal attitudes. Within this chorus of rebellious voices, Totah brings sharp comedic timing and fierce loyalty to the screen, embodying the modern teenager navigating social justice movements with both earnest passion and relatable flaws.

Sentimental summer camp tropes get a routine dusting off in this predictable family comedy about a ragtag group of misfit kids trying to save their beloved magic haven. Director Mark Waters leans heavily into nostalgia, utilizing slapstick routines, gentle mentorship arcs, and predictable rivalries to keep younger audiences engaged. While the script relies too heavily on familiar narrative beats, the bright production design and enthusiastic young cast maintain an upbeat, harmless atmosphere. Totah joins the youthful ensemble with natural charisma, adding much-needed energy to scenes that otherwise drift into familiar, overly formulaic territory.

Part eccentric detective procedural and part shaggy-dog L.A. comedy, this Netflix feature follows an oblivious homicide detective whose knack for solving crimes is entirely undermined by his personal neuroses. Directed with a loose, improvisational rhythm, the film relies almost entirely on Jason Bateman's deadpan charisma and a revolving door of quirky suspects and witnesses. The narrative structure meanders intentionally, feeling more like a filmed hangout session than a tight whodunit. Totah appears briefly within this sprawling ensemble, fitting comfortably into the film's eccentric, low-stakes California aesthetic without making a massive lasting impression.

Venturing into darker, more unsettling territory, this modern reboot tackles the grim underbelly of the internet through the lens of digital moderation and snuff ring conspiracies. The atmosphere is thick with paranoia, utilizing slick cyber-thriller tropes and unsettling imagery to question the cost of consuming violence online. Pacing issues and an over-reliance on familiar genre conventions occasionally hold the premise back from reaching its full shocking potential. Totah steps into this grim environment with an understated performance, attempting to ground a narrative that occasionally threatens to drown in its own cynical digital dread.

This low-budget family adventure relies on a familiar wish-fulfillment premise: a group of bored middle-schoolers find a chest of futuristic gadgets and proceed to cause suburban chaos. The production values and special effects struggle under the weight of limited resources, resulting in a cheap-looking aesthetic that often resembles direct-to-video filler. Performances from the young cast feel painfully uneven, hindered by clunky dialogue and unimaginative slapstick gags that wear out their welcome long before the credits roll. Totah does what is possible with the thin material provided, but the film remains a forgettable footnote in an otherwise vibrant career.